Do investment regulations compromise pension fund performance? : evidence from Latin America

This report assesses the impact of regulatory regimes on the market performance of private pension funds in Latin American countries that have undertaken reforms of their pension systems. It focuses, in particular, on the effects of " draconian " regulation, a set of rules on the industry...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Main Author: Srinivas, P S
Corporate Author: Banco Mundial
Other Authors: Yermo, Juan
Format: Book
Published: Washington, D.C. World Bank 1999
Series:World Bank Latin American and Caribbean studies. Viewpoints
Subjects:
Description
Summary:This report assesses the impact of regulatory regimes on the market performance of private pension funds in Latin American countries that have undertaken reforms of their pension systems. It focuses, in particular, on the effects of " draconian " regulation, a set of rules on the industry ' s structure, investment regime, and performnce. The authors conclude that while such rules may have achieved their basic objective of safeguarding workers ' retirement savings from financial systems that lack transparency and solidity, the rules are not without costs. These rules create distortions in asset management, limit opportunities for diversification, and consequently, hamper the performance of pension funds. This paper shows that the return to retirement assets, expected replacement rates, and hence the net welfare gain from pension reform, is lower under a draconian regulatory framework than under a more liberal pension fund investment regime. Important policy conclusions are that existing regulatory regimes should be liberalized as soon as possible to allow pension fund investments in a wide array of financial instruments, and that regulations should require evaluation of fund performance against market benchmarks, as opposed to exclusive focus on comparisons with industry averages. This report also suggests a review of the current structure of the private pension fund industry in Latin America and an evaluation against alternatives in light of actual performance experience.
Physical Description:iv, 50 p. : il.
Bibliography:Incluye bibliografía
ISBN:0-8213-4488-9